Why are food ingredients different in the US and Europe?

Some additives permitted in US foods are not authorised in the EU, a few work the other way round, and six colours need a warning label only in the EU.

The US and the EU assess food additives separately, and they do not always reach the same conclusion. That is one reason the same brand can list different ingredients in different countries. Below are the main documented differences.

Permitted in the US, not authorised in the EU

  • Titanium dioxide (E171): banned in EU food since 2022 after EFSA could no longer confirm its safety; the US still permits it. Read the guide
  • Potassium bromate: not authorised in the EU or UK; the US permits it within set limits. Read the guide
  • Azodicarbonamide (E927a): not authorised in the EU or UK; permitted in the US and Canada. Read the guide
  • Propylparaben (E216): authorisation withdrawn in the EU in 2006; still permitted in the US. Read the guide

Recently removed in the US

  • Brominated vegetable oil (BVO): FDA revoked its authorisation in foods in 2024; not authorised in the EU. Read the guide
  • Red 3 (erythrosine, E127): FDA revoked its authorisation in foods in 2025; the EU permits it only in a limited number of products. Read the guide

Permitted in both, but labelled differently

  • Six synthetic colours need the EU warning "may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children", including Red 40, Yellow 5 and Yellow 6. No such label is required in the US. Read the guide
  • Trans fats: the US removed the "generally recognised as safe" status of partially hydrogenated oils (2015); the EU limits trans fat to 2 g per 100 g of fat. Read the guide

Stricter in the US

  • Cyclamate (E952): not permitted in the US since 1969; permitted at approved levels in the EU. Read the guide
  • Quinoline Yellow (E104), Carmoisine (E122) and Ponceau 4R (E124) are permitted in the EU (with the warning label) but are not on the US list of colours permitted in food.

See it in real products

  • Mountain Dew: the US record lists Yellow 5; the German record lists beta-carotene. See the comparison
  • Gatorade: the US record lists Red 40; the German record uses sweet potato and carrot concentrates. See the comparison

Frequently asked questions

Why are American foods different from European foods?

The US and the EU assess additives separately. Some additives permitted in the US, such as titanium dioxide, potassium bromate and azodicarbonamide, are not authorised in the EU, and six colours need a warning label in the EU but not in the US. A few rules are stricter in the US, such as the ban on cyclamate.

Are European foods always healthier than American foods?

Not necessarily. The rules differ for specific additives, but sugar, salt and fat content depend on the product. Compare the labels of the specific products you buy.

Does the same brand use the same recipe everywhere?

Not always. For example, the Mountain Dew and Gatorade records we compared list different colourings in the US and Germany. Recipes vary by country and change over time.

Sources